Best ammo for self defense?

In the world of self-defense firearms, few debates are as enduring as the comparison between 9mm Luger (commonly called 9mm), .40 Smith & Wesson (.40 S&W), and .45 Automatic Colt Pistol (.45 ACP). These three calibers dominate the handgun market for personal protection, law enforcement, and concealed carry. Each has its loyal advocates, backed by decades of real-world use, ballistics testing, and evolving ammunition technology. But which one truly stands out for self-defense, particularly in the context of concealed carry?

This article dives deep into the advantages and disadvantages of each caliber, drawing from ballistic data, expert opinions, and practical considerations. We’ll examine factors like recoil, magazine capacity, stopping power, penetration, cost, and availability. By the end, we’ll conclude with a recommendation on the overall best choice for concealed carry self-defense. Whether you’re a first-time gun owner or a seasoned carrier, understanding these calibers can help you make an informed decision that could one day save your life.

berrysmfg.com

40 vs 9mm: Caliber Comparison | Berry’s Bullets Blog

A Brief History and Overview of Each Caliber

To appreciate the pros and cons, it’s essential to understand the origins and design intent behind each round.

9mm Luger

Developed in 1902 by Georg Luger for the German military, the 9mm (9x19mm Parabellum) quickly became a global standard. It was adopted by numerous armies during World Wars I and II due to its balance of power, size, and reliability. In self-defense contexts, the 9mm shines with modern hollow-point ammunition, offering velocities around 1,100-1,200 feet per second (fps) and muzzle energies of 350-400 foot-pounds (ft-lbs) in standard loads. Bullet weights typically range from 115 to 147 grains.

The 9mm’s popularity exploded in the U.S. during the 1980s with the rise of high-capacity “wonder nines” like the Beretta 92 and Glock 17. Today, it’s the most common handgun caliber worldwide, favored by the FBI and many police departments for its performance in gel tests and real-world scenarios.

.40 S&W

Born from the infamous 1986 Miami FBI shootout, where agents struggled with 9mm’s perceived lack of stopping power, the .40 S&W was introduced in 1990 by Smith & Wesson and Winchester. It aimed to bridge the gap between 9mm and .45 ACP, firing a 0.40-inch bullet at 900-1,100 fps with energies of 400-500 ft-lbs. Common bullet weights are 155-180 grains.

Initially adopted by the FBI and numerous law enforcement agencies, the .40 promised better penetration and expansion. However, its higher pressure (up to 35,000 psi) led to increased wear on firearms and sharper recoil, contributing to its decline in popularity by the 2010s.

.45 ACP

John Moses Browning’s 1905 creation for the Colt 1911 pistol, the .45 ACP was designed for maximum stopping power in military applications. It propels a heavy 230-grain bullet at 800-900 fps, delivering 350-450 ft-lbs of energy. Its low pressure (around 21,000 psi) makes it gentle on guns but produces significant recoil.

The .45 earned its stripes in two World Wars and remains a favorite among traditionalists for its large wound channels. However, its bulkier size limits magazine capacity in compact firearms, a drawback in modern self-defense scenarios.

Each caliber was engineered for reliability in combat or defense, but their differences become apparent when dissected for self-defense use.

Advantages and Disadvantages: A Head-to-Head Comparison

When evaluating these calibers for self-defense, key metrics include stopping power (ability to incapacitate a threat), penetration (to reach vital organs), expansion (for wound creation), recoil (for follow-up shots), capacity (rounds per magazine), cost, and availability. Modern jacketed hollow-point (JHP) ammunition has leveled the playing field, making “stopping power” more about shot placement than raw size.

Stopping Power and Ballistics

Stopping power is often misunderstood—it’s not just about bullet size but how it transfers energy to disrupt physiology. FBI standards require 12-18 inches of penetration in ballistic gel to ensure effectiveness through clothing and barriers.

• 9mm: Modern +P loads (e.g., Federal HST 124-grain) expand to 0.6-0.7 inches with 13-16 inches penetration. Muzzle energy averages 364 ft-lbs. It’s praised for reliable expansion and minimal over-penetration risk. Advantages: Consistent performance; disadvantages: Slightly less energy transfer than larger calibers in some tests.
• .40 S&W: Delivers 468 ft-lbs on average (e.g., Speer Gold Dot 180-grain), expanding to 0.65-0.75 inches with 12-15 inches penetration. It offers a balance, often matching or exceeding .45 in energy. Advantages: Superior stopping power in gel tests; disadvantages: Inconsistent expansion in older loads.
• .45 ACP: Around 416 ft-lbs (e.g., Hornady Critical Duty 220-grain), with expansion up to 0.75-0.9 inches and 12-14 inches penetration. Its large diameter creates bigger wounds. Advantages: Legendary “one-shot stop” reputation; disadvantages: Shallower penetration in some scenarios.

Overall, studies like Lucky Gunner’s analysis of 1,800 shootings show all three perform similarly with good ammo—incapacitation rates hover around 85-90% with proper placement.

Grok can make mistakes. Always check original sources.

Recoil and Shootability

Recoil affects accuracy and speed—critical in high-stress self-defense.

• 9mm: Lowest recoil (3-4 ft-lbs), enabling faster follow-ups. Ideal for beginners or smaller frames.
• .40 S&W: Snappier (5-6 ft-lbs), often called “sharp” recoil, leading to fatigue in extended practice.
• .45 ACP: Heavier push (4-5 ft-lbs), but smoother than .40 due to lower velocity.

Advantages for 9mm: Better control; disadvantages for .40 and .45: Harder on wrists, slower recovery.

Magazine Capacity

More rounds mean more chances to stop a threat.

• 9mm: 15-17+ in compact guns (e.g., Glock 19).
• .40 S&W: 12-14 in similar frames.
• .45 ACP: 8-10 typically.

9mm wins for sustained fire, a factor in FBI’s switch back from .40.

Penetration and Expansion

All meet FBI 12-18 inch gel standard with JHPs, but:

• 9mm: 13-16 inches, good expansion, low over-penetration risk.
• .40: 12-15 inches, balanced.
• .45: 12-14 inches, widest channels but risks under-penetration in barriers.

Modern ammo minimizes differences, but .45 excels in raw wound volume.

athlonoutdoors.com

9mm vs .40 vs .45: Which Chambering Has More ‘Stopping Power’?

Cost and Availability

• 9mm: Cheapest (~$0.20/round FMJ), most available.
• .40 S&W: Mid-range (~$0.30/round), less common now.
• .45 ACP: Priciest (~$0.35/round), steady supply but niche.

9mm edges out for budget-conscious shooters.

Other Factors

• Accuracy: All accurate in skilled hands, but lower recoil favors 9mm.
• Gun Size: 9mm allows slimmer, lighter CCW pistols.
• Training: Easier with 9mm due to less recoil and cost.

Concealed Carry Specifics: Which Caliber Fits Best?

Concealed carry prioritizes concealability, reliability, and quick deployment. Compact guns amplify recoil differences, making 9mm’s milder kick a big plus for accuracy under stress. High-capacity micros like the Sig P365 (9mm, 12+1 rounds) outperform .40/.45 equivalents in size and weight.

.40 S&W offers a power boost but with harsher recoil, potentially reducing proficiency in subcompacts. .45 ACP’s bulkier frames (e.g., 1911 Commander) make concealment harder, though fans praise its “one-shot” potential.

Availability matters—9mm is ubiquitous, ensuring ammo during shortages. For women or smaller-statured carriers, 9mm’s ease is often recommended.

gunmade.com

9mm vs. 40 S&W vs. 45 ACP: Ultimate Pistol Cartridge Battle

Conclusion: The Best Overall Choice

After weighing the evidence, 9mm emerges as the superior choice for concealed carry self-defense. Its low recoil, high capacity, affordable ammo, and modern ballistic performance make it versatile and effective. The FBI’s 2014 switch back to 9mm cited better shootability and similar terminal effects to .40/.45. Studies show no significant “stopping power” edge for larger calibers with proper JHPs.

.40 S&W is a solid middle-ground but fading due to recoil and cost. .45 ACP remains iconic for big-bore fans but sacrifices capacity and ease.